Indian cities are at a crossroads. With rapid urbanisation stretching civic services to their limits, the way cities are governed has become a matter of survival, not just administration. While the 74th Constitutional Amendment of 1992 laid the foundation for urban local self-government, comparing how cities elsewhere in the world are run offers valuable ideas for making Indian municipalities more capable, accountable, and citizen-friendly.
Table of Contents
- Why look abroad?
- The Indian starting point: promises and gaps of the 74th Amendment
- Lesson one: Define intra-tier functional responsibilities clearly
- Avoiding the obligatory-discretionary trap
- Lesson two: Strengthen state-local linkages
- Metropolitan and district planning committees
- Lesson three: Promote flexible and inclusive planning
- Lesson four: Ensure legal frameworks for enforcement
- Lesson five: Build local administrative and technical capacity
- Technology and knowledge management
- Lesson six: Improve financial planning and autonomy
- Lesson seven: Involve citizens in governance
- Putting it together: a roadmap for Indian cities
Why look abroad?
Urban governance across the world has been shaped by decades of experimentation. Countries like Brazil, South Africa, the United Kingdom, Japan, and several European states have tried different ways of distributing powers between national, state, and city governments. Many of them started from positions similar to India’s, struggling with unclear responsibilities, weak finances, and limited local capacity. Studying their journeys helps us identify what works and what doesn’t, without repeating avoidable mistakes.
The UN-Habitat has pointed out that urban governance systems in many countries are unfit for purpose, often marked by inadequate decentralisation, insufficient resources, and ill-defined distribution of responsibilities between different levels of government. This observation fits the Indian situation closely and sets the stage for learning from comparative experience.
The Indian starting point: promises and gaps of the 74th Amendment
The 74th Constitutional Amendment formally recognised urban local bodies as the third tier of government, creating three types of municipalities: municipal corporations for larger urban areas, municipal councils for smaller urban areas, and nagar panchayats for transitional areas between rural and urban. It also mandated states to transfer eighteen functions listed in the Twelfth Schedule, covering urban planning, land-use regulation, water supply, public health, sanitation, and solid waste management.
However, much was left to state discretion. As a result, implementation has been uneven. Analysts have noted that by 2013, only 11 out of 31 states and union territories had transferred all 18 functions to urban local bodies. India’s municipal revenues as a share of GDP remain strikingly low compared to Brazil and South Africa, reflecting a gap between constitutional promise and ground reality.
Lesson one: Define intra-tier functional responsibilities clearly
One of the most consistent findings from international experience is the importance of clarity in who does what. When responsibilities overlap between state agencies and municipal bodies, accountability is diluted and citizens suffer. UN-Habitat notes that in many countries, especially in the Global South, the ill-defined distribution of responsibilities leads to duplication of roles and gaps that create institutional wars, resulting in poor service delivery.
In Brazil and South Africa, the constitutional and legal frameworks spell out municipal functions in far greater detail than in India. South Africa, after democratisation, consolidated more than 1,100 racially segregated municipalities into 283 units, each with clear jurisdictional and functional boundaries. For India, the takeaway is that state legislatures should stop treating the Twelfth Schedule as a wish list and instead assign each function unambiguously, with clear performance expectations.
Avoiding the obligatory-discretionary trap
Several Indian state municipal acts divide municipal functions into obligatory (must be performed) and discretionary (may be performed). This distinction, inherited from colonial-era laws, often becomes an excuse for neglect. Cities might treat storm-water drainage or urban greening as discretionary and deprioritise them until a crisis hits. International practice increasingly rejects this binary. Functions are either assigned or not, and once assigned, they must be delivered. Moving away from the obligatory-discretionary distinction can help Indian cities treat all core urban services with equal seriousness.
Lesson two: Strengthen state-local linkages
Cities do not exist in isolation. They sit within state administrative frameworks, and the quality of that relationship determines how much autonomy cities actually enjoy. A common Indian complaint is that mayors and councillors have limited power over funds and functionaries, which reduces urban local bodies to civic service agencies rather than genuine self-governments.
In the United Kingdom, the Greater London Authority Act of 1999 gave the Mayor of London substantial power, including setting the annual budget and negotiating directly with national agencies on transport and housing. In Japan, a system of designated cities enjoys powers comparable to prefectures in specified domains. In Brazil, the 1988 Constitution elevated municipalities to a full level of federation, giving them direct constitutional status alongside states and the union. These arrangements show that strong state-local linkages are not about centralising control but about guaranteeing cities a seat at the table and a share of resources.
Metropolitan and district planning committees
The 74th Amendment provided for Metropolitan Planning Committees and District Planning Committees to coordinate planning across municipal and rural boundaries. In practice, these committees have either not been constituted or function ineffectively in most states, leaving urban planning fragmented across multiple agencies. Other federal systems handle metropolitan coordination through formally empowered regional bodies with statutory powers. Activating MPCs and DPCs, and giving them real authority over land, transport, and environment decisions, would plug a serious gap.
Lesson three: Promote flexible and inclusive planning
Rigid master plans drawn up every twenty years cannot keep pace with cities that double in size within a decade. International practice has moved toward rolling plans, strategic spatial frameworks, and participatory budgeting. The celebrated experiment in Porto Alegre, Brazil, where residents directly decide portions of the municipal budget, has inspired hundreds of cities worldwide.
In India, only a handful of states mandate citizen engagement at the municipal level. According to one analysis, as of 2023 only three out of 35 states and union territories mandated public consultation on city budgets, and only five had enacted community participation laws creating ward committees and area sabhas. Embedding flexibility and participation into planning law, rather than leaving them to the goodwill of officials, would bring Indian practice closer to international norms.
Lesson four: Ensure legal frameworks for enforcement
A plan on paper means little without enforcement. South African and European cities generally have dedicated municipal police, building inspectors, and environmental enforcement wings empowered by clear statutes. In India, enforcement is often split between municipal staff, state revenue officials, and police, with no single agency held accountable for violations of building codes or encroachment of public land.
International experience suggests that enforcement works best when the enforcing body is close to the community, legally empowered to issue fines and demolitions, and subject to judicial review. Strengthening municipal enforcement powers, backed by fast-track urban tribunals, could transform compliance with zoning, construction, and pollution rules.
Lesson five: Build local administrative and technical capacity
An empowered city is useless without competent staff. Research by the National Institute of Urban Affairs highlights that depleted institutional capacity continues to threaten the very existence of urban local self-governments. Many Indian municipalities lack qualified town planners, engineers, finance professionals, and data analysts.
Countries like Germany and Japan have well-established municipal civil services with specialised cadres for urban management. South Africa runs formal training academies for local government officials. The Government of India has tried to move in this direction through the Jawaharlal Nehru National Urban Renewal Mission and later the Atal Mission for Rejuvenation and Urban Transformation, which encouraged states to create separate municipal administration cadres. However, implementation has been patchy. A systematic investment in a professionalised municipal cadre with clear career progression would mirror international best practice.
Technology and knowledge management
Digital governance is another area where international peers have moved ahead. Comparative studies of Brazil, South Africa, and India have shown how geographic information systems and e-governance platforms can make city administration more transparent and responsive. Indian cities have begun adopting GIS-based property tax systems and online grievance portals, but scaling these requires in-house technical talent, not just outsourced contracts.
Lesson six: Improve financial planning and autonomy
Finance is the oxygen of local government. The comparison is stark: India’s total municipal revenues constituted just 0.72 percent of GDP in 2019-20, whereas the same figure stood at 6 percent in South Africa and 7.4 percent in Brazil. The gap reflects weak property tax administration, limited access to user charges, and heavy dependence on state and central transfers.
International experience points to three reforms. First, predictable fiscal transfers based on transparent formulas, similar to South Africa’s equitable share system. Second, own-revenue empowerment, letting cities levy and collect a wider set of taxes and user charges. Third, access to capital markets through municipal bonds, as practised widely in the United States and increasingly in Brazil. India has begun with municipal bond issuances by cities like Pune and Hyderabad, but the base needs to widen.
Lesson seven: Involve citizens in governance
Ultimately, cities belong to their residents. International good practice treats citizens not as beneficiaries of schemes but as co-producers of urban services. The World Cities Report 2022 highlights how civil society organisations in cities across Africa, Asia, and Latin America bridge the gap between the state and excluded groups, advocating for rights and collective action.
India has strong legal provisions for ward committees, but their functioning varies dramatically across states. Activating these forums, linking them to participatory budgeting, and providing them with real information and authority would bring governance closer to the people. Kerala’s Kudumbashree network, with millions of women members, shows how citizen self-organisation can transform both service delivery and political voice.
Putting it together: a roadmap for Indian cities
International lessons do not translate mechanically. India’s federal structure, diversity, and scale demand context-sensitive adaptation. Yet the direction is clear. Cities need clearer mandates, stronger institutions, better finances, skilled staff, and genuine citizen participation. Reforms will need coordinated action from the Union government, state governments, and municipalities themselves, supported by civil society and academia.
The UNDP’s recent policy dialogue on urban governance in Asia and the Pacific argued for anticipatory, adaptive, and agile governance to navigate the complexities of urbanisation. That framing captures the spirit of what Indian cities need: governance that looks ahead, learns, and adjusts, rather than reacting to crises after they unfold.
What do you think? Which international practice feels most urgently needed in your city, and what is the one change that would make your local municipality visibly more accountable to you as a resident?
References
- https://unhabitat.org/topic/urban-governance
- https://www.tandfonline.com/doi/full/10.1080/07352166.2016.1271614
- https://www.orfonline.org/english/expert-speak/the-role-of-the-central-government-in-strengthening-urban-local-self-governance
- https://polityprober.in/2025/05/24/what-are-the-key-provisions-of-the-74th-constitutional-amendment-act-and-to-what-extent-has-it-succeeded-or-failed-in-realizing-the-vision-of-empowered-urban-local-governance-in-india/
- https://niua.in/sites/default/files/2025-07/2024_2_%20Impact%20of%20the%2074th.pdf
- https://www.academia.edu/67603657/Baud_et_al_2013_Spatial_Knowledge_Management_in_Urban_Local_Government_E_Governance_in_India_Brazil_South_Africa_and_Peru_synthesis_of_Fieldwork_Reports
- https://unhabitat.org/sites/default/files/2022/07/chapter_8_wcr_2022.pdf
- https://decentralization.net/2025/01/reimagining-urban-governance-in-asia-and-the-pacific/
Leave a Reply