Public policy-making is rarely the work of a single ministry, a single government, or a single official sitting at a desk. It is a layered, interconnected process where the Union, states, and local bodies must talk to each other, and where ministries and departments at the same level must coordinate closely. These interactions, known as inter-governmental relations (IGR), form the invisible scaffolding on which every major scheme, from rural housing to healthcare, actually stands.

Understanding how vertical and horizontal linkages function, and how parliamentary committees hold the entire system accountable, gives us a clearer picture of why some policies succeed while others stall. Let us walk through these linkages and the institutional mechanisms that keep them functional.

Table of Contents

What are inter-governmental relations?

Inter-governmental relations refer to the continuous interactions between different orders of government and between different agencies within the same order. Since human interactions sit at the core of IGR, institutional mechanisms are required to facilitate coordination among political and administrative incumbents. These mechanisms are the channels through which policies get negotiated, resources are shared, and disputes are resolved.

Broadly, IGR operates along two axes. The vertical axis connects the Union government with state governments and state governments with local self-government institutions. The horizontal axis connects ministries, departments, and agencies that sit at the same level of the governmental hierarchy. Both axes must function well for policy-making to be coherent.

Vertical linkages: Connecting Union, state, and local governments

Vertical linkages describe the relationships between different tiers of government. The Constitution itself recognises this layered structure. The Seventh Schedule divides legislative powers through the Union List, State List, and Concurrent List, allowing both the Union and the states to legislate on matters of shared concern. This division is not a wall; it is a framework for collaboration.

When the Centre rolls out a flagship scheme, it depends heavily on the states and local bodies for execution. Centrally Sponsored Schemes such as the Mahatma Gandhi National Rural Employment Guarantee Act and the Pradhan Mantri Gram Sadak Yojana are funded by the Centre but executed by the states, relying on shared financial and administrative responsibilities. Without coordinated vertical linkages, these schemes would remain paper promises.

Institutional mechanisms for vertical coordination

Several bodies have been set up to facilitate vertical coordination:

The Inter-State Council is a constitutional body established under Article 263. It was created through a Presidential Order on 28 May 1990 and is chaired by the Prime Minister, with Chief Ministers of all states, Chief Ministers of UTs with legislatures, administrators of other UTs, and six Union Cabinet Ministers nominated by the Prime Minister as members. Its mandate is to investigate and discuss subjects of common interest between the Union and the states, and among states.

The NITI Aayog, which replaced the Planning Commission in 2015, has taken on the task of fostering cooperative federalism. According to its mandate, NITI Aayog works through structured support initiatives such as meetings between the Prime Minister and Chief Ministers, subgroups of Chief Ministers on subjects of national importance, sharing of best practices, and capacity development of State and UT functionaries.

The Finance Commission, constituted under Article 280, handles the fiscal dimension of vertical coordination by recommending the distribution of tax revenues between the Union and the states. The Zonal Councils, created under the States Reorganisation Act of 1956, promote inter-state cooperation on regional issues.

Challenges in vertical coordination

Vertical linkages are not always smooth. Political differences between the ruling parties at the Centre and in the states can create friction. The Inter-State Council, despite its constitutional backing, has met only about 12 times since its establishment in 1990, and the Punchhi Commission recommended at least three meetings per year. Administrative overlaps, fiscal tensions, and shifting political equations can all weaken vertical ties.

The COVID-19 pandemic offered a live demonstration of both the strengths and strains. The central government issued guidelines, procured vaccines, and coordinated supplies, while state governments tailored lockdowns and local health measures. The experience showed how essential vertical coordination is during a crisis and how easily it can become contentious when priorities diverge.

Horizontal linkages: Coordination at the same level

Horizontal linkages operate between governments and agencies at the same level. Two state governments coordinating on river water sharing is horizontal IGR. Two ministries of the Union government working on a single policy is also horizontal IGR. So is a group of municipal bodies pooling resources for waste management.

At the local level, horizontal intergovernmental relations emphasise collaboration among local governments through inter-municipal initiatives such as regional conferences, joint utility services, and coordinated municipal departments that allow them to pool resources and expertise. The logic is simple: shared problems need shared solutions.

Why horizontal coordination is essential in policy-making

Most policy issues do not fit neatly into the mandate of a single ministry. Consider a socio-economic development programme. It may require inputs from the Ministry of Rural Development for the scheme design, the Ministry of Finance for budgetary allocation, the Ministry of Agriculture for crop-related components, the Ministry of Health and Family Welfare for nutritional support, and the Ministry of Women and Child Development for gender-specific interventions.

If these ministries work in silos, the policy fragments. If they talk to each other, the policy becomes coherent. The Cabinet Secretariat and the Prime Minister’s Office play significant roles in stitching together such inter-ministerial efforts, ensuring that the left hand knows what the right hand is doing.

Mechanisms that support horizontal coordination

The GST Council is perhaps the most visible modern example of institutionalised horizontal coordination, though it also has vertical dimensions. It operates on shared decision-making between the Centre and states on tax rates, exemptions, and the administration of the Goods and Services Tax. Groups of Ministers, inter-ministerial committees, and secretary-level coordination meetings serve similar functions in other policy areas.

At the state level, horizontal coordination happens through regular meetings of secretaries, joint task forces for specific projects, and state-level coordination committees. At the local level, municipal bodies and panchayati raj institutions coordinate on matters such as watershed management, solid waste disposal, and inter-village infrastructure.

Challenges in horizontal coordination

Horizontal linkages face their own set of difficulties. Inter-departmental silos are a familiar problem. Ministries often guard their turf, reluctant to share data, credit, or authority. Resource constraints can make joint work harder, especially when departments compete for the same budgetary pool. The absence of formal coordination mechanisms for certain cross-cutting issues can lead to duplication and gaps.

Research on energy policy implementation shows how this plays out in practice. One study of rural electrification in Jharkhand found partial alignment at the state level around off-grid electricity connectivity objectives, but a lack of institutionalised roles for NGOs and fragmentation of governance as one of the main causes of coordination failure. When mandates are fuzzy, outcomes suffer.

The role of parliamentary committees in ensuring accountability

Coordination is only half the story. The other half is accountability. If policies are designed and implemented by a web of ministries and governments, how does Parliament keep watch? The answer lies in parliamentary committees, which serve as the legislature’s instrument for detailed scrutiny.

According to the Comptroller and Auditor General’s office, financial accountability of the executive to the Legislature is ensured through a system of committees, including three financial committees: the Estimates Committee, the Public Accounts Committee (PAC), and the Committee on Public Undertakings (CoPU), all set up under the Rules of Procedure and Conduct of Business in the Lok Sabha. Each committee has a distinct role in the policy cycle.

The Public Accounts Committee

The PAC is often called the mother of parliamentary committees. It was introduced in 1921 after its first mention in the Government of India Act of 1919, also known as the Montford Reforms, and is constituted every year under Rule 308 of the Rules of Procedure and Conduct of Business in Lok Sabha.

The committee has 22 members, 15 from the Lok Sabha and 7 from the Rajya Sabha, with a one-year term. Since 1967, the Chairperson has been drawn from the opposition, a convention that underscores the non-partisan intent of the committee. Ministers are not eligible to be members, which further protects its independence.

The PAC’s primary function is to examine the audit reports of the Comptroller and Auditor General after they are tabled in Parliament. In doing so, it scrutinises whether public funds have been spent legally, whether expenditure conformed to sanctioned authority, and whether financial propriety was observed. High-profile cases such as the 2G spectrum allocation and coal block allocation examinations show how the PAC can bring major policy lapses into public view.

The committee’s influence, however, goes beyond fault-finding. By flagging systemic weaknesses, it pushes ministries to redesign processes and tighten controls. As noted during its centenary celebrations, the Public Accounts Committee has examined public expenditure not only from a legal and formal point of view to identify technical irregularities, but also from the point of view of economy, prudence, wisdom, and propriety.

The Estimates Committee

If the PAC looks backward at how money was spent, the Estimates Committee looks forward at how money should be spent. It examines the budget estimates of ministries and suggests reforms to improve efficiency in public expenditure. Its recommendations touch on organisational structure, administrative practice, and the balance between economy and efficiency.

The committee functions by preparing and reviewing estimates, constituting sub-committees for detailed work, and tabling its reports in the Lok Sabha. Its role in shaping policy is quieter than the PAC’s but arguably just as significant, because it catches problems before money is committed rather than after.

Beyond these financial committees, 24 Department-related Standing Committees scrutinise bills, budgets, and policies associated with specific ministries. They provide a forum where MPs engage with domain experts, civil servants, and affected stakeholders away from the glare of the television cameras that dominate floor proceedings.

As an analysis of parliamentary functioning notes, committees examine policy issues in their respective ministries and make suggestions to the government, which has to report back on whether these recommendations have been accepted, after which committees table an Action Taken Report showing the status of government action on each recommendation. This cycle creates a paper trail of accountability.

Why these linkages matter for effective policy-making

Effective policy-making in a large, diverse democracy is not a solo performance. It depends on vertical linkages that connect the Centre, states, and local bodies so that national priorities translate into local action. It depends on horizontal linkages that bring together ministries and departments so that multi-sectoral issues are addressed holistically. And it depends on parliamentary committees that hold the entire apparatus to account by scrutinising estimates, audits, and policy outcomes.

When any one of these strands weakens, policy suffers. Schemes get stuck at state capitals, ministries issue contradictory guidelines, or financial irregularities go undetected. When all three work together, the machinery of governance becomes responsive, transparent, and capable of delivering on its promises.

What do you think? In your view, which is harder to strengthen in practice, vertical coordination between governments or horizontal coordination between ministries? And do you think parliamentary committees like the PAC and Estimates Committee carry enough authority to actually shape policy outcomes, or do they function more as watchdogs after the fact?

How useful was this post?

Click on a star to rate it!

Average rating 0 / 5. Vote count: 0

No votes so far! Be the first to rate this post.

We are sorry that this post was not useful for you!

Let us improve this post!

Tell us how we can improve this post?

References
  1. https://mpra.ub.uni-muenchen.de/74251/1/MPRA_paper_74251.pdf
  2. https://ijirl.com/wp-content/uploads/2025/05/COOPERATIVE-FEDERALISM-IN-INDIA-NAVIGATING-THE-INTERPLAY-OF-COLLABORATION-AND-COMPETITION-IN-A-DIVERSE-NATION.pdf
  3. https://anantamias.com/inter-state-council/
  4. https://niti.gov.in/cooperative-federalism
  5. https://decentralization.net/2024/12/how-does-intergovernmental-coordination-strengthen-local-governance/
  6. https://www.researchgate.net/figure/Horizontal-and-vertical-institutional-relations-of-policy-sectors_fig1_314034253
  7. https://cag.gov.in/cen/new-delhi-iv/en/pages/single/7515
  8. https://www.drishtiias.com/daily-news-analysis/public-accounts-committee-pac
  9. https://www.pib.gov.in/PressReleaseIframePage.aspx?PRID=1778078

Comments

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Public Policy and Analysis

1 Understanding Public Policy

  1. Significant Concepts: Public and Policy
  2. Nature of Public Policy
  3. Policy-Making and Decision-Making
  4. Policies and Goals
  5. Policy-Making and Planning
  6. Policy Analysis and Policy Advocacy
  7. Policy Analysis and Policy Management
  8. Public Policy: Scope
  9. Typologies of Policies
  10. Policy Inputs, Policy Outputs, and Policy Outcomes
  11. Significance of Public Policy

2 The Policy Cycle

  1. Policy Cycle: Approach
  2. Identifying the Underlying Problem
  3. Determining Alternatives for Policy Choice
  4. Forecasting and Evaluating the Alternatives
  5. Making a Choice
  6. Policy Implementation
  7. Policy Monitoring
  8. Policy Outcomes
  9. Policy Evaluation
  10. Problem Structuring
  11. Limitations of Policy Analysis

3 Models of Public Policy

  1. Systems Model for Policy Analysis
  2. Institutional Approach to Policy Analysis
  3. Rational Policy-Making Model
  4. Lindblom’s Incremental Approach
  5. Dror’s Normative-Optimum Model
  6. Political Public Policy Approach
  7. Mixed Approach by Hogwood and Gunn

4 Importance of Public Policy- Contemporary Context

  1. Importance of Public Policy
  2. Developing Study of Policy Science
  3. Political and Administrative Reasons
  4. Role of the State in Contemporary Context
  5. National Policy Agenda in a Global Context

5 Policy Sciences

  1. Lasswell and the Idea of Policy Sciences
  2. Policy Sciences: Nature, Scope and Utility
  3. Policy Sciences and Emerging Crisis
  4. Agenda for the Policy Sciences
  5. New Directions and Perspectives

6 Role of Inter-Governmental Relations in Policy-Making

  1. Inter-governmental Relations
  2. Models of Inter-governmental Relations
  3. Inter-governmental Relations: Policy-making Structures and Processes
  4. Inter-governmental Relations: Horizontal and Vertical Linkages in Policy-making
  5. Role of Inter-governmental Relations in Policy-making: Review

7 Role of Planning Commission and National Development Council in Policy Formulation

  1. Role of Planning Commission
  2. Planning Commission: Organisational Structure
  3. National Development Council: Role and Composition
  4. Planning Procedure: Formulation of Five-Year Plan and Annual Plans
  5. Role of Planning Commission: Review

8 Role of Cabinet Secretariat and Prime Minister’s Office in Policy-Making

  1. Role of Cabinet Secretariat in Policy-Making
  2. Role of Prime Minister’s Office in Policy-Making
  3. Advisory Committees/Councils to Prime Minister
  4. Prime Minister’s Office: Intervention
  5. Role of Prime Minister in Policy-Making

9 Role of Civil Society Organisations in Policy-Making

  1. Civil Society Organisations in India
  2. Civil Society Organisations: Typology
  3. Government – Civil Society Interface
  4. Pavement Dwellers in Mumbai
  5. Tribals in Gujarat
  6. Implementation of Decentralisation of Power in Bangalore
  7. Delhi Government: Bhagidari
  8. Civil Society Organisations: Challenges

10 Role of International Agencies in Policy-Making

  1. United Nations: Organisational overview and Development Approaches
  2. UN: Specialized Agencies
  3. Policy-Making: Role of International Agencies
  4. Role of International Agencies in Policy-Making: Analysis and Suggestions

11 Constraints in Public Policy Formulation

  1. Processes of Choice: How Rational’?
  2. Requirements in Rationality
  3. Policy Craft: Role of the Bureaucracy
  4. Role of Civil Society
  5. Value Constraints: The Welfare Predicament
  6. Systems Approach to Policy-Making

12 Public Policy- Implementation System and Models

  1. Policy Implementation: System and Issues
  2. Implementing with a Network
  3. Allocating Tasks to Personnel
  4. Making Decisions
  5. Implementation Approaches/Models

13 Role of Various Agencies in Policy Implementation

  1. Elements for Policy Implementation
  2. Modes of Policy Delivery and Implementers
  3. Roles and Responsibilities of Administrative Organisations
  4. Legislative Bodies
  5. Judicial Bodies
  6. Civil Society

14 Policy Implementation Problems

  1. Problems in Policy Implementation
  2. Conceptual Problems
  3. Political Problems
  4. Administrative Problems
  5. Lack of Public Involvement

15 Monitoring of Public Policy-I

  1. Monitoring of Public Policy: Meaning and Significance
  2. Approaches to Policy Monitoring
  3. Constraints in Policy Monitoring
  4. Remedial Measures for Effective Monitoring

16 Monitoring of Public Policy-II

  1. Techniques of Policy Monitoring
  2. Techniques for Monitoring Technical Performance
  3. Techniques for Monitoring Time Performance
  4. Techniques for Monitoring Cost Performance
  5. Policy Outcomes
  6. Effective Policy Monitoring Mechanism

17 Understanding Policy Evaluation

  1. Policy Evaluation: Nature and Significance
  2. Criteria for Evaluation
  3. Policy Evaluation: Types, Approaches, and Methods
  4. Evaluating Agencies
  5. Problems in Policy Evaluation

18 Ascertaining Policy Impact

  1. Policy Impact: Significance and Types
  2. Measuring/Assessing the Impact
  3. Policy Impact: Problems and Suggestions

19 Policy Analysis

  1. Policy Analysis
  2. Types of Policy Analysis
  3. Methods and Techniques in Policy Analysis
  4. Ethics in Policy Analysis
  5. Process of Policy Analysis

20 Policy Analysis- Methods and Techniques-I

  1. Social Cost-Benefit Analysis (CBA)
  2. Advantages and Limitations of CBA
  3. Identification of Costs and Benefits
  4. Commonly Used Cost-Benefit Measures for Policy Comparisons
  5. Choosing a Cost-Benefit Method
  6. Inter-Sectoral Input-Output Analysis
  7. Transactions Table
  8. Production Coefficients in Input-Output Analysis
  9. Forecasting – Using Input-Output Production Coefficients